|
|
|
|
LETTERS Have a comment? Let us know what you think!
|
The letters are the opinion of our readers and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Nation and its staff. VOLUME 13-07 Destroying to build anew Thursday February 2, 2006, will always be a special day for me. That morning in La Tuque I bought a sledgehammer and I got to use it. I started hammering away near the doorway (corner) of the residential school on the girls’ side. Hardly anybody was around, everybody had already left, except the demolition crew. I got to see with my own eyes, the highest section (the gym) of the school fall over. Standing there with my sledgehammer, I was witnessing a historical moment in Canada. That is the history I will tell my children and grandchildren. VOLUME 13-03 Card or not, Crees have right to health care This is in response to Will Nicholl’s editorial in the Nation (“Deadly Bureaucracy,” October 28, 2005). It was unfortunate that you contracted acute tonsillitis and had to run around to see how you can be served as a beneficiary. I hope that you are now completely healed from your tonsillitis. To begin, I would like to explain to you the jurisdictional responsibility of Cree Board of Health and Social Services of James Bay. I think that it is important to understand this in order to avoid certain expectations in the future. The health care and social services system in Quebec is based on geography. There are 18 regions. The CBHSSJB is region 18. The CBHSSJB has the same role and responsibility for the health and wellbeing of all people living in region 18 (category 1 and 2 lands of Iiyiyiu Aschii). Whether an individual is a beneficiary or not does not change the services provided. Any person living or traveling on the territory will be attended to in any emergency even in the absence of a medical card. The CBHSSJB is currently in a phase of reorganization and we are lacking an accessible client information system that would normally contain relevant patient information. If it had been in place at the time of your incident, you would have called the attendee and he or she would have recommended you to go directly to the hospital without worrying about a medical card. We hope to have this kind of information system in place in the next few years. The Cree Patient Services in Montreal exists specifically to oversee beneficiaries with specific needs that come down from their communities to receive specialized services. They are not directly involved in the care of patients except for those who are referred by doctors from one of the Cree communities. (Some Public Health workers are still temporarily in Montreal for historical reasons and because there are not enough houses in Iiyiyiu Aschii at this time to accommodate them. They are involved in population health approaches and not in individual care provision.) I hope this clarifies how our system currently functions and that it may help you and your readers to have a better understanding of how we try to accommodate beneficiaries to the best of our capacity. Sincerely, Joanne Bezzubetz, Executive Director, CBHSSJB VOLUME 12-26 Beyond Borders What is it like to be a Cree woman, who lives in a Cree community outside of the “Cree” territory, and face issues of discrimination and personal rejection based on geographical factors? The most prevalent geographical factor includes the Ontario/Quebec provincial border that was created with the unequivocal purpose of division. The theme of borders and division play into many factors in my life, more specifically with the divisions that exist because of the James Bay Northern Quebec Agreement of 1975. Since when did the Cree territory give way to the amorphous and contradictory natures of borderlines and boundaries? Apparently when the border was created in the 1800s and again when it was solidified in 1975. I was born in Moose Factory, Ontario, three years after the JBNQA was signed on behalf of the Cree and all of the future Cree born into the agreement thereafter. The dynamics of the migration to Moose Factory for many Quebec Cree are diverse, but valid nonetheless. Families relocated because they were recruited for trapping in northern Ontario, or for employment opportunities with the railroad or at the hospital. Perhaps the most effective example of relocation to use, and only because so many Cree have some connection to this, would be Horden Hall residential school. One can speculate that people still harbor issues from their experience and incorporate that into their policy and decision making, such as excluding Moose Factory as part of the territory. Besides the categorization of Cree land in Quebec by the JBNQA, which gives legal verification, how is it that the city of Val D’or is more of a Cree community than Moose Factory? Where can you find a greater number of beneficiaries raising their generations in one spot outside of the territory than Moose Factory? Sadly, I thought that Cree directives would include the goal of increasing the Cree nation to include all of its members and beneficiaries, making one strong and united nation. For a long time I did not really know what MoCreebec did or what it was accomplishing. Occasionally, I would get a MoCreebec newsletter believing that they were sent to me out of obligation because MoCreebec was receiving money for my band affiliation and beneficiary number, which I was surprised to learn, was not the case at all. When MoCreebec and the CMHC housing program gave me the opportunity to rent an apartment in 1997, I began to notice the acts of kindness and efforts that were extended to “Quebec Indians” like me and other people who fell through the cracks of the divisions and limitation of services on Moose Factory Island. I have decided that I will always be strongly affiliated with MoCreebec, an organization that has managed to create and accomplish so much despite the fact that they are continuously denied core funding for their programs from governments and the Cree, and who are so blatantly discriminated against by the policies their own people maintain. Each year, I have been given ample opportunity to grow and learn while I work at MoCreebec. This article came out of the space and freedom that working with MoCreebec provides me with. My growth is equally important as the work that I contribute to the organization. My cumulative experience at MoCreebec is the motivation behind writing this long overdue article. I sit and watch the Cree arguing with each other through the non-Aboriginal lawyers we hire to settle legislation initiated by a non-Aboriginal government in a non-Aboriginal court. One of the most obvious failures of a legal system that claims to be fair and just is that its creation and design was specifically for people with money. The people with money and power can use the system to drain their opponents’ resources. Is this the Cree way? I use this reality to demonstrate the fact that ingrained colonialistic policies and practices are written within the words of the JBNQA and the New Agreement, and yet the focus seems to be solely on dollar signs. I find it interesting that section 3.2.7, although approved by the Cree, was a government-initiated idea. Is there that much lack of faith by Cree leaders in Cree people that we feel like we have to restrict their ability to exist as beneficiaries and Cree people beyond the territory? That we had to specifically design a clause in the agreement that keeps Indians on their reserves? Out of sight and out of mind is the phrase that comes to mind. The obvious fact that the Cree are letting words on paper decide who they are is absurd. I am Cree no matter where I choose to reside or where I am domiciled. These limitations have such a great influence on who we are as Cree people, we should be asking ourselves if we have made any steps forward with sovereignty or have we been colonized so successfully that these new agreements are not modern day treaties, but modern-day tools of colonialism and control that we are efficiently implementing amongst our own people? I live 45 km from the province of Quebec and the Cree territory. As a Cree woman I refuse to let an invisible line declare that I am no longer Cree, define who I am or contain me to any place without the freedom of choice. This border is a representation of a physical demarcation of our people and culture, although I believe its credibility is fictitious. We share collective memories and knowledge as Cree people. Our intellectual property is archived and inherent in all our beautiful Cree children who are born through our bloodlines. I am a Cree woman no matter where I go, and my heart and identity go well beyond borders. Anonymous
VOLUME 12-23 History lost for video games So the Rupert River will follow the same path as many great rivers have gone before. Land clearings, river diversions, cooperation with tallymen, assessments, relocations of human and wildlife, and the list goes on. Surveys carried out in 2000 and 2002 could no longer be valid because of the strange environmental impacts caused by man and nature in 2005. I was at the LG-1 reservoir the other day. At this reservoir, Hydro-Quebec showed tourists the great project of the century. Yet, on the other hand, they also showed the production of a sod dwelling that is centuries old and used by the Cree of long ago. The presence of that sod hut left a larger impact on tourists than the dam. Why? Because it is historical and can never be replaced. Also that same day there were people from Moose Factory. The grandmother of the group told a small boy, "This is where the power comes from so you can play your games on television." The information didn't bother the boy, as does many individuals in the Cree Nation. I blame the many Cree leaders who should know better. Those leaders who never made a move to save a river - one beautiful river. This river can never be replaced once it is diverted. Margaret Cromarty,
They're out there They seem to walk aimlessly around the village of Chisasibi every day and night. On weekends, these beings take over the village. They can barely stand, let alone walk; yet they make their way to God knows where. They usually hang out in packs. With lost balance, blurred-vision, and the reduced ability to speak clearly, they are undoubtedly looking for more booze, drugs or a party. Their numbers are staggering, and they create fear for people who are trying to spend a well-deserved weekend after a long week's work. These people who seem to enjoy being seen in a drunken state and seem to take pleasure in scaring the elderly and young children do not seem to respect the townspeople. For instance, they find their way to the commercial centre, bother people there, vomit on the public floor, and spit on some poor soul as he or she comes in or goes out of the building. They do the same at the General Store, at the arena, but I have yet to see them at the hospital. Thank God they stay away from the hospital. In addition, they fight on the streets, pass out on them, and they even interrupt a walking-out ceremony on a quiet summer weekend morning. All of the acts mentioned above are done under the watchful eyes of young children who are simply playing outside innocently. What do you suppose these children think when they see drunks behaving strangely around them? Do they run away screaming fearing for their safety, or are they accustomed to seeing drunks walking around town with beer cans in their hands? The answer to this question is both. Some kids get scared while others simply ignore the drunks. This is what I want to discuss: children, as we all know, can easily be influenced. By being constantly exposed to drunks and their acts, the children begin to see these drunken behaviours as normal, as something that plays a part in their lives. The images of drunken adults and even young teenagers become imprinted in their innocent young minds. Next thing we know these children grow up and do exactly the things they saw. They end up getting alcohol and drugs, and start doing the same exact acts they witnessed as children. Why? Because they have learned that alcohol and drugs, and the behaviours that are created by these products, are valued around them. These children soon see that parties and walking around town under the influence of drugs and alcohol are simply ways of life here in Chisasibi, the normal and cool thing to do. But we know better don't we? If we do not, we should. Children should not be exposed to sights such as these. They deserve better. They deserve to have fun and be happy, to explore and grow in an environment free from drunks who use foul language in public, who beat up each other for some unknown reason, and countless other unacceptable acts done publicly. Let us rear our children in a safe environment free from unwanted behaviours that are created by the consumption of drugs and alcohol. Wandering drunks should remain indoors, away from those people who simply want to have a nice day or weekend. Let us think about our children. Let us protect them from unwanted stimuli, from things that can harm their future. Those of you who like to drink, please drink and remain indoors, for our children - our future leaders - are watching. A concerned Chisasibi resident
JBNQA serves Cree interests I wanted to comment on your editorial, "Elections are opportunity for nation building," to provide a different understanding of what the James Bay and Northern Quebec Agreement (JBNQA) represents to the Crees. My father, Joseph Petagumskum, who passed away this spring, was the Chief of Whapmagoostui when that legal instrument was negotiated. Eventually, he signed that important accord on behalf of our community. My father, in his own way, let me know that the James Bay and Northern Quebec Agreement was a legal instrument the Crees are using to develop a relationship with the governments of Canada and Quebec. This relationship has been in place for over 30 years now, and over that time the Crees have used the JBNQA as a means of ongoing nation building. My father also explained to me that the JBNQA helped our people reverse the historical neglect of the Crees' needs by the Canadian and Quebec governments. Cree control of education, health, human resources, and other areas of importance are directly tied to the JBNQA. The JBNQA is not "one of the biggest sellouts," as you put it. [Ed. note: the editorial actually argues against this point of view. The Nation has never taken this position.] It is not a road map leading to the alienation of Cree land and rights, as some would have us believe. The JBNQA has become the shield with which the Crees have successfully protected the Cree culture and various types of Cree rights from external governments and big business. The JBNQA has also helped promote and protect the general welfare of the Crees. Before the JBNQA the Crees had nothing to use legally to promote and protect their traditional way of life. To this day, even though Aboriginal rights are protected under Section 35 of the Constitution of Canada, many First Nations remain defenseless without a legal instrument to use to advance their rights and interests. Over the last 30 years the Cree Nation leadership has been taking practical, incremental measures to ensure its realization. The strange thing is that many Crees do even see that this has been taking place all along and within the context of the JBNQA. It is well-advised political campaigns and strategies, combative negotiations, and carefully planned court battles, using legal instruments such as the JBNQA, which have earned the Cree Nation respect nationally and internationally. Ill-advised agendas can only serve to undermine the hard-earned credibility and respect that is collectively enjoyed by the Cree Nation. Can we realistically expect any worthwhile agreements to be acquired when some advise us to "take a minimum of one year to consider any agreement affecting the Crees in the long term"? It is a no-brainer that there are civil servants in the governments of Canada and Quebec who feel that it is their job to protect the public purse and prevent such agreements with First Nations from being concluded. Our national leadership has done very well in supporting the whole nation. I trust my father's advice still today and I resent those who have yet to prove themselves denigrating his judgment. Weemish Petagumskum Whapmagoostui
::EMAIL FEEDBACK:: from the Nation website Poison kudos and pens This is a response to your article titled "Poison...HISTORY" concerning the Ouje-Bougoumou contamination. In the story it begins that it started five years ago when people asked game wardens if there was anything wrong with the fish, and were told nothing. Luckily to say, someone listened. However, some people may ask how the American geologist, Christopher Covel, first arrived in Ouje-Bougoumou and who was that person who asked him if the mines could kill the fish. Well, I'm confident and delighted to say that person was Mr. David Bosum Sr. of Ouje-Bougoumou; he was the first to finally take the stand. David has a business called Nuuhchimi Wiinuu Cree Cultural Tours. It invites tourists all around the world to have a taste of the Cree Culture in the northern atmosphere. However, an American geologist named Christopher Covel and a couple of other Americans contacted David to book for one week. When they arrived they were taken out in the bush to experience the Cree way of Life. It was at the end of their tour when they were taken to a campground near Chibougamau Lake. It was then David asked Chris if the mining could make the fish sick. And so, the story begins... I believe a lot of thank-yous are owed to Mr. David Bosum Sr. from the people of Ouje-Bougoumou for his bravery. Naomi Bosum
I first want to thank the Nation to be interested and to continue to publish articles on environmental issues and, in particular, on the problem of contamination in Ouje area. Yet, I want to mention an error in the article. Dr. Eric Dewailly is working for the Institut national de santé publique (INSPQ) and Université Laval (Québec) and not at all for the Quebec Environment Ministry. Bonnier Viger Ed. note: You're right, we slipped. The Nation regrets the error.
The information you obtained for your article was available last year. The impression in the story is that you had to dig it up because somebody was hiding it. The timing and use of this dated information was to shock the community of OJ and influence their vote. Will, your standards are getting a bit low. Bill Namagoose Executive Director, Grand Council of the Cree Ed. Note: The Grand Council of the Cree may have been aware for a year that the waters around Ouje-Bougoumou have been poisoned. But that doesn't explain why the GCC didn't denounce the situation or discuss it with the people of OJ (much less the Nation), nor why the Quebec government wouldn't do the same. The Nation will always publish information of public interest, dated or not.
Father-son reunion a tearjerker I think it would make people cry if they saw it on APTN about Daniel and Cory meeting together after 29 long years. I felt my tears when I heard their story. Daniel told the story to my dad and my dad told me. I can't wait to meet my uncle too, I play hockey also and most of his cousins and nephews plays. Byron Sam
The first time I heard that he had finally met his dad I was crying because I didn't realize he would accept his dad. I'm happy for both of them that they finally met after 29 years. We can't wait to meet him. Greta
More legends, please I want to read more of the past or the legends of the Cree people. Our Elders are getting old and some have passed on already. We should take this chance to still hear the stories from our elders while we still can. They are the key to the way it used to be. John
Hydro-Quebec doesn't get it So what else is new? Hydro-Quebec never has understood, and as long as they keep trying to write the Cree up as some kind of sociological exercise they never will. Maybe if they put some of the same passion they put into their fight against the loss of French language and culture they might. They should stop focusing on our differences and enjoy all the wonderful things that we all share as human beings. Mark Eitzen
I read your commentary on the EIA with great interest. As a fellow academic I agree very much with Harvey Feit's assessment and was pleased to see your coverage in the Nation. But there is one key issue that is not highlighted in Feit's assessment that I think is of great importance - and I have raised this issue with CEAA and HQ as well as the GCC. Currently, there is no adequate gender impact assessment in the EIA, except in terms of health. This is a grievous oversight and I think Cree women and girls need to have an economic and cultural assessment in addition to simply a review of potential health impacts. I am an expert on social impact assessments and spent 18 months in James Bay on my doctoral thesis in the mid-1990s. I hope you can also highlight the need for a gender impact assessment in a future issue of the Nation. In other parts of the world, indigenous women are demanding this (e.g., Voisey Bay) and I think Cree women and girls deserve equal consideration. Dr Gail Whiteman
Send Christmas dinner, please I came to Montreal two years ago to live here. I have a question that needs to be answered. I think all the native people that live here should have funding from our bands to have a feast at least for Christmas holidays. Not only for these people, but for the natives who come from the north to have some resources from our leaders. The Makivik Corporation gives some traditional food that is flown from the north for the Inuit in Montreal. I am Cree, and if I don't eat traditional food for some time I crave it. We people should not be forgotten, because we don't live on our reserves. We're still native people, but prefer to live somewhere we want to. So tell our leaders there are some of us who still exist. Annie Sheshamush
AUGUST, 2005 CSB
JULY, 2005 Thank God for Cree School Board MAY, 2005 A Cry for One More River more Ten reasons a Cree School Board student should be grateful 1. No student loans to pay off after graduation According to CBC News Online, the average debt on student loans is $25,000, which usually takes 10 years to pay. As CSB students, we graduate debt-free. moreAPRIL, 2005 Still in Search of a Kidney Donor Hello, my name is Yvonne Bosum and I am from the Ouje-Bougoumou Cree Nation. I am 36 years old, and have a wonderful son who is 9 years old. At the moment I live in Fort-St-James, British Columbia. I know I am miles away from my family, and it is not easy for me at the moment. Five years ago I was diagnosed with kidney failure; both of my kidneys failed on me and now only 20 per cent of each kidney works. I used to be on the peritoneal home moreFreedom Open Letter to the Waswanipi Survivors of the Mohawk Residential School (Brantford, Ontario) I have attended meetings both in London and conducted meetings in the community to relate information and to gain instructions from the survivors to convey to the lawyers working on the lawsuit. I am a member of the Steering Committee for the advancement of the lawsuit, which meets in London to give instructions to the law team and to receive information on the progress of the team’s efforts.
Rallye International du Chibougamou As a supporter of the Rallye International du Chibougamou and as a parent of one of the participants in this past weekend’s events, I must, after much reflection and deliberation, express to you my most profound disappointment...
Nemaskau Eenouch So Much for a New Relationship: Premier Jean Charest, Mr. Thierry Vandal, President of Hydro-Quebec Production and Mr. Sam Hamad, Minister of Natural Resource along with certain “dignitaries” of the Municipalité de la Baie-James, made a surprise but very subtle visit to the Eastmain-1 Camp site at the end of January 2005, which for those who knew thought was just a visit to the Eastmain-1 work camp and the construction site. FEBRUARY, 2005 Applause for Hughboy I think it’s high time somebody spoke out about what’s happening in our communities.
Ouje-Bougoumou, politically challenged I think that Tony Hughboy should be given a chance to run. He always makes good remarks. Sometimes it’s good to have an outside person come in and make a difference. He did make a point about the expenses by the council members. Bringing their spouses all expenses paid. January, 2005 My dearest true Love Andrew, I Remember, Part 1: NOVEMBER, 2004 Alcohol still hurts – 1 October, 2004 Follow-up letter to ‘Simon’s
Story’ |
||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||